Home › How Party Wall Surveyors Are Appointed › The Third Party Wall Surveyor

The Third Party Wall Surveyor

The Third Party Wall Surveyor

A third surveyor provides a way to settle disputed party wall matters when two surveyors have been appointed. Selection happens at the start; a referral may come later. If you are unsure why a third surveyor has been named or what a referral could involve, we can explain the process and the documents needed to understand your position.

Our award service starts from £700. A third surveyor referral is a separate matter with its own scope and costs.

What the third surveyor does

A third party wall surveyor is the surveyor selected by the two separately appointed surveyors under section 10 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. Either owner or either appointed surveyor can call on the selected third surveyor to determine disputed matters within the Act.

This is sometimes described as a tie-breaker role because it can resolve disagreement between the two surveyors. The statutory power is wider than that shorthand: a referral is not restricted to a deadlock between them.

A third surveyor is not appointed automatically in the single agreed surveyor route. Our appointments overview explains how the roles fit together. Any referral costs need separate consideration; our £700 starting price for an award service is not a cap on third surveyor fees.

Simple Transparent Pricing

Party Wall Notice

Free

Professional preparation and service

Schedule of Condition

from £350

Comprehensive photographic report

Party Wall Award

from £700

Complete legal agreement

Fixed fees for extensions, loft conversions, basements & new builds

When the third surveyor is selected

The two surveyors must select a third surveyor promptly once they are separately appointed. Having the selection in place early means there is an identified surveyor available for a referral if disputed matters need a determination later.

The selection must be in writing. It gives the process an identified person to whom disputed matters can be referred. It does not mean the third surveyor has begun a determination or that the owners automatically owe a full referral fee.

The Act also provides a fallback procedure if a surveyor refuses or fails to participate in selection. That procedure has specific conditions and should not be replaced by an owner simply choosing a different third surveyor themselves.

What triggers a referral

Either owner or either appointed surveyor may make a referral under section 10(11). A disagreement over an award condition, damage issue or costs may prompt it, provided the matter falls within the statutory remit.

  1. Identify the disputed matter and the relevant notices, appointments and works.
  2. Check the written selection of the third surveyor.
  3. Refer the issue with the documents and evidence needed to understand it.
  4. The third surveyor considers the matter and makes the necessary award within the Act’s powers.

A focused referral is more useful than sending every disagreement between the neighbours without explaining what needs determining. Before proceeding, establish whether the concern belongs under the Act and whether a served award creates an urgent legal deadline.

Read about party wall dispute resolution.

What the third surveyor decides

The third surveyor can determine disputed matters connected with works covered by the Act. These can concern the right to carry out relevant work, its timing or manner, and related matters such as reasonable costs.

The role does not confer a general power to determine land ownership, grant planning permission or decide every complaint about a building project. Some issues require a solicitor, structural engineer or another professional alongside the party wall process.

The referral should therefore identify both the question and the basis on which the surveyor is being asked to decide it. A clear scope helps the owners understand what the determination can resolve and what will remain outside it.

How binding is their determination?

The third surveyor makes an award under the Act. A valid award is binding within the statutory powers, subject to the county court appeal route.

Either owner may appeal within fourteen days beginning with the day the award is served on them. Seek urgent independent legal advice if you are considering a challenge. Further discussion or correspondence should not be assumed to extend that period.

A third surveyor referral should not be treated as an automatic replacement for a court appeal against an existing award. The issue, powers and timing need checking. Our award page explains the distinction between preparation, service and appeal.

Who pays the third surveyor

The award determines who pays the reasonable costs of the referral. The building owner may pay, but the allocation depends on the disputed matter and circumstances. Ask about the fee basis and possible cost responsibility before proceeding.

Cost questionWhat to establish
Has a referral been made?Selection alone is different from carrying out a determination.
What is being referred?The scope and evidence affect the professional work required.
How will the fee be charged?Ask for the applicable fee basis and any payment arrangements.
Who must pay?Reasonable costs are allocated through the statutory determination, not assumed from the original quote.

Unnecessary or unreasonable expense can affect the costs position. Ask about the likely further work before making a referral, without assuming the person who raises the issue must always pay or can never be charged.

Will the third surveyor always be involved?

A third surveyor can be selected without ever being asked to determine a matter. The two appointed surveyors may resolve the issues between them and serve an award without a referral.

How long a referral takes

There is no single completion period for every referral. A narrow fee question with complete documents differs from a damage dispute needing inspection and technical evidence.

Ask what documents are needed, whether an inspection is required and when a determination is expected. Keep the contractor informed if the referral affects the programme. Existing notice requirements and award conditions still need to be observed while the matter is being considered.

Frequently Asked Questions

A third surveyor is selected by the two separately appointed surveyors to determine disputed matters if a statutory referral is made. The role is part of the two-surveyor route under section 10.

The two appointed surveyors select the third surveyor in writing. The Act provides a specific fallback where selection fails; the owners do not ordinarily make that selection themselves.

The third surveyor acts when a disputed matter is referred under section 10(11). Either owner or either appointed surveyor can refer, so a deadlock between the two surveyors is not the only trigger.

A valid award is binding within the Act’s powers, subject to appeal. The county court appeal period is fourteen days beginning with the day the award is served on you. Seek urgent legal advice if necessary.

The statutory costs determination allocates reasonable fees. The building owner may pay, but that is not guaranteed for every referral. The issue and circumstances can affect the allocation.

The statutory selection is made by the appointed surveyors, not directly by an owner. You can ask who has been selected and raise relevant concerns through the appropriate process.

The time depends on the disputed matter, evidence, access and any technical assessment required. Request an estimate for the actual scope rather than rely on a standard number of days.

Get a fixed quote

Send the notices, appointment letters, written third surveyor selection and a brief explanation of the disputed matter. Tell us whether an award has already been served.

Request your fixed quote

    Call 07436 999 523Get a free quote